If you’re in Lexington, Kentucky, you don’t have to search the internet to find nostalgic candy that’s still being made. While many classic treats have disappeared over the years, plenty of old-school favorites have quietly remained in production. Whether you’re reliving childhood memories or discovering these sweets for the first time, these retro candies have stood the test of time and are finding new fans every day.
Bonomo Turkish Taffy
Many people assume Bonomo Turkish Taffy disappeared decades ago, but it’s still around. Famous for its chewy texture, fans often freeze the bar before smacking it on a hard surface to break it into bite-sized pieces. It’s a fun tradition that’s just as satisfying today as it was generations ago.
Zero Bar
A true vintage candy bar with a unique story. It has been around since the 1920s and stands out because of its white fudge, caramel, peanut, and almond combination covered in white chocolate-style coating. It’s a great “people can’t believe this still exists” candy.
Zagnut Bar
The Zagnut Bar has never been a mainstream candy bar, which is exactly why so many people are surprised it’s still available. With a crispy peanut butter center covered in toasted coconut instead of chocolate, it’s unlike almost every other candy bar on the market.
Twin Bing
If you’ve never heard of the Twin Bing, you’re not alone. This regional favorite features a cherry nougat center surrounded by chocolate and chopped peanuts. It’s one of those hidden gems that candy enthusiasts love introducing to friends.
Nik-L-Nip Wax Bottles
Nik-L-Nip Wax Bottles are more than just candy—they’re an experience. Bite off the top, sip the sweet flavored syrup inside, and then chew the wax bottle. While many people remember them from their own childhood, Nik-L-Nip is seeing a resurgence with kids today who are discovering the fun of this unique candy for the first time. The interactive experience of drinking the flavored liquid and chewing the wax makes it stand out from modern sweets and helps explain why new generations are becoming fans.
Choward’s Violet Mints
One of the most unique candies still being made is Choward’s Violet Mints. Their delicate floral flavor isn’t something you find every day, making them a conversation starter and a favorite among adventurous candy fans.
Cow Tales
Cow Tales continue to be a favorite thanks to their soft caramel exterior and creamy filling. They’re available in several delicious flavors and remain one of the most recognizable old-fashioned candies still sold today.
Razzles
Few candies can say they transform while you eat them, but Razzles do exactly that. They begin as fruity candy before gradually turning into chewing gum. Whether you choose the Original, Sour, Berry Mix, or Tropical varieties, they’re just as fun today as they’ve always been.
Creme Savers
After disappearing from shelves for several years, Creme Savers made a welcome return. Fans can once again enjoy flavors like Strawberry & Creme, Orange & Creme, Chocolate & Caramel, Peach & Creme, and Raspberry & Creme, bringing back a favorite from the late 1990s and early 2000s.
Chick-O-Stick
The Chick-O-Stick is a classic candy that many people remember from childhood but are surprised to learn is still being made today. First introduced decades ago, this crunchy treat combines roasted peanut butter and toasted coconut for a flavor that’s completely different from most modern candy bars. Its unique texture and old-fashioned taste have helped it maintain a loyal following, while new generations of candy lovers continue discovering why this retro favorite has lasted so long.
Classic candy has a way of bringing back memories that newer treats simply can’t replace. Whether you grew up with these favorites or are discovering them for the first time, these timeless candies prove that some of the best sweets never really go out of style.
3401 Nicholasville Road, Lexington, KY 40503
Store Hours: 10am to 8pm Monday to Saturday and 12 to 6 Sunday.
Come visit us and explore our huge selection of nostalgic candy—you just might rediscover an old favorite or find a new one you’ll love.